Groundwork ← Back Founder Operations   The cluster All guides
Groundwork
Founder Operations

How to Design an Interview Process When You Have Never Hired

A five-stage interview process for a first hire: scorecard, screening call, structured interview with a rating scale, paid work sample, references and offer. With the questions you cannot ask and one hire worked through hour by hour.

Share
On this page
    Quick answer

    A good interview process for a small business has five stages: write a one-page scorecard for the job, screen applications and run a 15-minute phone call, hold one structured interview where every candidate gets the same questions and the same rating scale, pay your finalists for a short work sample, then check references and make the offer. For one part-time hire it takes about 10 hours of your time over three weeks. Structure is the part that matters: in the largest recent review of hiring methods, structured interviews predicted job performance better than any other method tested.

    If you have never hired anyone, most guides to the interview process will not help you. They are written for the candidate, telling you how many rounds to expect and how to answer the dreaded "tell me about yourself". You are on the other side of the table, with no HR team, no recruiter and no template from a previous job.

    The good news is that a first hire does not need a long process. It needs a short one that you run the same way for every candidate, so you are comparing people against the job and not against your memory of who you liked.

    Below are the five stages, what each one is for, the questions to ask and the ones you cannot, and a worked example of one real-sized hire from job post to offer, with the hours it takes.

    The 5 Stages of an Interview Process

    Every stage has one job: to cut the list down using information you could not get at the stage before. Here is the whole interview process on one line.

    The interview process for a first hire
    1. Scorecard Before you post What done looks like, and the 3 to 5 skills that get it done.
    2. Screen 15 minutes Applications against the must-haves, then a short call.
    3. Structured interview 45 minutes Same questions, same order, scored on the spot. The stage that predicts most
    4. Work sample 1 to 2 hours, paid A small slice of the real job.
    5. References and offer Final week Confirm what you saw, then make the offer in writing.

    Hiring for a few hours a week? Keep all five stages and shorten each one. Skipping the scorecard is what breaks the rest.

    Each stage removes people using something the previous stage could not show you.

    Why this order? The cheap checks come first and the expensive ones last. Reading an application costs you two minutes. A work sample costs you money and a candidate's afternoon, so only two or three people should ever reach it.

    Step 1: Write a Scorecard Before You Post the Job

    A scorecard is one page that says what the person will deliver and what they need to be able to do. Write it before the job post, because everything after it gets measured against it.

    It has three parts:

    • The outcomes. Two or three results you expect in the first six months, written as things you could check. "Invoices go out within two days of every finished job" beats "helps with admin".
    • The must-haves. Three to five skills or experiences the person cannot do the job without. If you list ten, none of them are must-haves.
    • The deal-breakers. The practical limits: hours, location, start date, pay range. These are what the screening call checks.

    This step answers the question most first-time hirers skip: what would a great hire actually do differently from an average one? The US Office of Personnel Management, which designs hiring for federal agencies, puts it plainly. Interview questions based on the specific competencies critical to job success show high levels of validity and rater agreement. Your scorecard is where those competencies come from.

    Before you write the post, decide whether this is an employee at all. If you will set the hours and the method, the person is probably a W-2 employee, not a contractor, and 1099 vs W2 works through what that costs you.

    Step 2: Screen Applications, Then Make a 15-Minute Call

    Screening has one job: to remove people who cannot meet the must-haves or the deal-breakers, quickly and politely.

    Read applications against the scorecard. Give each one about two minutes and sort it into yes, maybe or no on the must-haves alone. Ignore the things not on your list, such as which school they went to or how polished the CV looks.

    Then a 15-minute call with the yes pile. Not an interview. You are checking three things:

    • The deal-breakers: hours, pay range, start date, location.
    • That they understand what the job is, in their own words.
    • One must-have, with a single "tell me about the last time you did X" question.

    Say the pay range on this call, out loud. If it does not work for them, you have both saved an hour.

    Aziz's take: The phone screen is where first-time hirers are too generous. You meet someone warm and easy to talk to, and you move them forward even though they missed a must-have. That one kindness costs you a 45-minute interview, a work sample and an awkward rejection later. Be kind on the call and strict on the list.

    Step 3: Run One Structured Interview

    This is the stage that decides the hire, and the one where structure pays most. A structured interview means every candidate gets the same questions, in the same order, and you score each answer against a scale you wrote in advance.

    The evidence for doing it this way is unusually strong. In 2022, Paul Sackett and colleagues re-ran decades of hiring research in the Journal of Applied Psychology, and structured interviews came out with the highest mean validity of any method, at .42, ahead of job knowledge tests (.40), work samples (.33) and cognitive ability tests (.31). OPM adds that interviews with more structure show higher validity, better rater agreement and less adverse impact.

    That last point matters when you are the only interviewer. Structure is how one person stops "I liked them" from deciding the hire.

    How to build it, in four steps:

    1. Write one or two questions for each must-have. Five to seven questions in total fills 45 minutes.
    2. Mix behavioral and situational questions. Behavioral asks what they did; situational asks what they would do. Both are explained below.
    3. Write a rating scale for each question before the first interview. OPM recommends labeling at least three proficiency levels, with an example of what an answer at each level sounds like.
    4. Score each answer straight after it is given. Not at the end of the day, when the last candidate is the one you remember.

    Here is one question with its scale, for a role that deals with your clients:

    Score"Tell me about a time a client was unhappy with something you delivered. What did you do?"
    1No real example, or the client was simply wrong. Talks about what they "usually" do.
    2A real example, but they fixed it only after being told to, or cannot say what changed.
    3A real example: they found out why, fixed it, and told the client what they had done.
    4All of 3, plus they changed something so it did not happen again, and can say what.

    Write the scale in your own words, for your own job. The point is that a 3 means the same thing for the first candidate and the fourth.

    The questions you cannot ask. The EEOC's small business guide recommends you avoid asking about race, color, religion, sex, national origin or age, including indirect versions such as which church someone attends or whether they plan to have children. Before an offer, you cannot ask about a disability or anything likely to reveal one, such as current medication or past workers' compensation claims. You can ask how they would perform a specific task in the job. Writing every question in advance is the simplest way to make sure none of these slip in.

    What Is a Behavioral Interview?

    A behavioral interview asks candidates to describe what they actually did in a past situation, on the principle that past behavior is the best predictor of future behavior. "Describe a time you had to chase a late payment" is behavioral. "What would you do if a client stopped paying?" is situational.

    OPM describes both as effective, and says behavioral questions have shown higher validity where the work is highly complex, such as professional and managerial jobs.

    The weakness of a behavioral question is that it rewards experience. Someone early in their career may simply not have a story. For those candidates, a situational question about the same skill is the fairer version. Use both, and score both on the same scale.

    Listen for the verb. "I called the client" is an answer. "I would usually reach out" is not, and that is your cue to ask, "Can you think of a specific time?"

    Step 4: Pay Finalists for a Short Work Sample

    A work sample is a small, real slice of the job, done by the candidate and judged by you. Two or three finalists, one to two hours each, paid at the rate the job pays.

    Good work samples look like the job's first week:

    • An operations assistant: tidy a messy client list into your format, and draft the reminder email for overdue invoices.
    • A bookkeeper: categorise a month of sample transactions and flag the three that need a question.
    • A writer or designer: one short piece from a real brief, not a pitch for your whole brand.

    Pay for it. An unpaid "test project" asks your best candidates, the ones with other options, to work for free, and it blurs the line between assessment and free work. Paying also makes it easy to ask for something real.

    Judge it against the scorecard you wrote in step 1, not against the other finalist. The question is whether this is the standard the job needs.

    Step 5: Check References, Then Make the Offer

    References come last because they confirm, they do not discover. Call two for your top candidate, ideally people who managed them or paid them.

    Ask about the must-haves, with the same kind of questions as the interview: "Can you tell me about a time they handled an unhappy client?" Then ask the one question that tends to get an honest answer: "Would you hire them again?" A pause is an answer too.

    Make the offer in writing, with the pay, hours, start date and anything that depends on a trial period. Then tell everyone else who reached the interview stage, the same week. A short, kind no is the last part of a good process.

    One deadline lands right after the offer for an employee. You must complete Section 2 of Form I-9 within three business days of their first day of paid work, according to USCIS. Start on a Monday, and that is Thursday. For a contractor, the paperwork is different, which 1099 vs W2 covers.

    Their first two weeks are part of the hire too. A written handover document for the tasks they are taking over saves you answering the same questions twenty times.

    Worked Example: One Part-Time Hire, Start to Finish

    Here is the whole interview process for one realistic first hire: a part-time operations assistant, 20 hours a week at $25 an hour, for a small service business. The job post draws 40 applications. The hours are the owner's.

    Owner time for one part-time hire, by stage
    1. Scorecard1 page1h
    2. Applications40 x 2 min1h 20m
    3. Phone screens8 x 15 min2h
    4. Interviews4 x 55 min with scoring3h 40m
    5. Work samples2 reviewed40m
    6. References, offer2 calls + offer1h

    Total: 9 hours 40 minutes of owner time, plus $100 for two paid work samples (2 finalists x 2 hours x $25). Interviews are 45 minutes each plus 10 minutes of scoring.

    More than a third of the time goes on the structured interviews, the stage that predicts the most.

    Week 1. The owner writes the scorecard: invoices out within two days of each finished job, every client email answered within one working day, and the booking calendar kept clean. Must-haves: written English clients can rely on, comfort with spreadsheets, and having handled customers before. The job goes up with the pay range in it.

    Week 2. 40 applications, read in two sittings. 8 make the yes pile on the must-haves. 8 short calls, and 2 drop out on hours or pay. That leaves 6, and the owner invites the strongest 4 to interview.

    Week 3. 4 structured interviews, six questions each, scored straight after every answer. Two candidates clearly lead on total score. Both do a paid two-hour work sample: clean a real (anonymised) client list and draft an overdue-invoice reminder. One is plainly stronger. Two reference calls back it up, and the offer goes out on Friday.

    The whole process for one part-time hire takes about 10 hours of your time and $100 in paid work samples. Against a 20-hour-a-week role, that is less than one week of the person's own working time.

    Aziz's take: Ten hours feels like a lot when you are already doing everything yourself, which is exactly why people hire. But the expensive version is the one without a process: a single friendly chat, a hire on gut feel, and three months later you are starting again with the same ten hours still ahead of you. The process is the shortcut.

    How Many Interview Rounds Do You Need?

    For a first hire, two conversations and one work sample are enough: the 15-minute screen, the 45-minute structured interview, and the paid task. Adding rounds rarely adds information when there is only one interviewer, because you end up asking the same questions twice.

    Add a second interview only if it brings a different person or a different test. A partner who will work closely with the hire, or a trusted client meeting them for twenty minutes, is a real extra round. A second chat with you is not.

    Speed matters too. Good candidates are talking to other employers, and a process that drags across six weeks loses them. Three weeks from post to offer is a realistic target for a small business.

    The Four Phases of a Single Interview

    Inside the 45-minute structured interview itself, four phases keep it on time:

    PhaseTimeWhat you do
    1. Open5 minExplain the business, the job and how the interview will run, including that you will take notes.
    2. Your questions25 minThe same prepared questions, in the same order, scored as you go.
    3. Their questions10 minAnswer honestly, including the hard parts of the job.
    4. Close5 minSay what happens next and when they will hear from you. Then keep to it.

    Phase 3 is part of the assessment as well. Good candidates ask about the work: what a normal week looks like, what went wrong with the last person, how they will know they are doing well.

    What Is the 30-60-90 Rule in an Interview?

    The 30-60-90 rule is a prompt to describe what someone would do in their first 30, 60 and 90 days in the job. Candidates usually meet it as a question, and some bring a written plan.

    For you, it is useful in two ways. Asked of your finalists, it shows whether they understood the job: a good answer spends the first 30 days learning, and only then starts changing things. And written by you, before you hire, it is a short version of your scorecard: what you expect done by day 30, by day 60 and by day 90.

    Do not turn it into homework. A ten-minute conversation in the interview tells you as much as a slide deck, and it does not filter out good candidates who have no time for unpaid work.

    Red Flags to Watch For in an Interview

    Most red flags show up as a pattern across answers, not a single moment. These are the ones worth writing down:

    • No specific examples. Every answer is about what they "usually" or "would" do, even after you ask for one real time.
    • Everyone else was the problem. Each previous employer or client was difficult, and nothing was their own responsibility.
    • No questions about the work. They ask only about pay, hours and time off, or have not looked at what your business does.
    • The story changes. What they said on the phone screen does not match the interview or the references.
    • Missed basics. Late without a message, or ignoring the instructions for the work sample, in the one stretch where people are trying hardest.

    Nerves are not a red flag. Plenty of people interview badly and work well, which is one more reason the work sample sits after the interview.

    Hiring is one of the systems that holds the rest of the business together. Our business operations guide covers the others, and if you are still deciding whether this job needs an employee at all, start with hiring a virtual assistant.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Five steps work for a small business. Write a one-page scorecard of the outcomes and must-have skills, screen applications against it and make a 15-minute call, run one structured interview with the same questions and rating scale for everyone, pay two or three finalists for a short work sample, then check references and make the offer in writing.
    For a small business, two conversations and a work sample are enough: a 15-minute phone screen, a 45-minute structured interview and a short paid task. Add a further round only if it brings in a different person, such as a partner, or a different kind of test. A second interview with the same person asking similar questions adds time, not information.
    Opening, your questions, their questions, and the close. In a 45-minute interview that is roughly 5 minutes to explain the job and the format, 25 minutes of prepared questions, 10 minutes for the candidate's questions, and 5 minutes to explain what happens next and when.
    It is a prompt to describe what someone would do in their first 30, 60 and 90 days in the job. As the employer, ask finalists for it in a short conversation to check they understood the role, and write your own version before you hire so you know what success looks like by each date.
    An interview built on questions about what the candidate actually did in past situations, such as "describe a time you dealt with a late-paying client". It rests on the idea that past behavior predicts future behavior. Situational questions ask what they would do instead, and are the fairer choice for someone without much experience.
    From the hiring side: no specific examples even when asked for one, blaming every previous employer or client, no questions about the work itself, a story that changes between the screen, the interview and the references, and missing basics such as turning up late without a message. Nerves on their own are not a red flag.